No. of view: 1495    Reply: 7

Holding dividend stocks is worse than holding properties

Damon Ho

Hong Kong does not own a well-established retirement system, so most workers must prepare their own retirement plans. Among the various kinds of these plans, the simple and effective self-made long-term income with dividend stocks is welcomed by many retirees. 

One friend of the author, who has planned to retire two years ago, realized that the prospect of the property market was gloomy, so he decided to sell out his residential property for HK$ eight million. With this cashflow, he set up a Hk$ seven million dividend stocks portfolio with a yield return of 5% annually and put the remaining Hk$ one $million in time deposit as reserved fund. 

My friend's investment portfolio provides dividends up to Hk $ 350,000 per year, and his two-person household depends on these dividends to live a prosperous retirement life in mainland China. Until recently, my friend still holds these stocks portfolio, and the receivable dividends is unchanged, but the market value of his portfolio has fallen by 40% and it is equivalent to a book loss of HK$2.8 million. This portfolio’s value drops to Hk$ 4.2 million, along with the remaining one million time deposit, the total asset value of his personal wealthy is about 5.2 million. 

If my friend sells his property now, the market value of his property will be reduced from    eight million two years ago to 6.8million at this moment. He believes that it is more advantageous to hold stocks than properties, but the result has proved him wrong.

My friend was anxious about the prospects of Hong Kong stocks, and asked the author whether he should sell his stock holdings and then switch to the time deposit for a 5% yield return. The author replied that the yield return on his existing stocks portfolio had risen to about 8% due to the decline value of its stocks, but he could only receive a return of 5% after selling stocks for a time deposit, and his annual income will be decreased Hk$ 126,000 to 210,000 from 336,000. 

The author does think that if his portfolio’s dividend keeps steady, it seems better to hold his equities portfolio, but if the stock price continues to fall, its receivable dividend is most likely to be cut in the future, so whether to switch the investment strategy is indeed a dilemma. 

 
I want to leave a message
Nickname
Message
/ Opinion
Captcha
 
Member Login
Login ID / Nickname
Password
1. HK The government revealed its deficit was 177.7b 2023-11-04 13:58:14
The government revealed that its deficit was $177.7b for the first six months of 2023.
 
Expenditure for April to September was at $355.6b and revenue was $131.3b. A deficit was reported after taking into account the proceeds of $46.6b garnered from the issuance of green bonds.
 
The Government said the deficit was mainly "because some major types of revenue, including salaries and profits taxes, are mostly received towards the end of a financial year."
2. HK GDP rose by 4.1% in Q3 2023-11-05 20:31:40

Hong Kong’s gross domestic product (GDP) rose by 4.1% in the third quarter of 2023,  thanks to improved domestic demand and services trade.

This is a faster rise than the 1.5%, according to advanced estimates from the Census & Statistic Department (CenStat).

On a seasonally adjusted quarter-to-quarter comparison basis, GDP increased by 0.1% in real terms in Q3 compared with Q2.

3. Hang Seng Bank no changes prime rate 2023-11-06 09:13:17

Hang Seng Bank has made no changes to its Hong Kong dollar prime lending rate.

It remains at 5.875% per annum (pa), the bank said in a press release.

4. Government recorded 2,938 sale agreements in Oct 2023-11-07 17:33:26

The government recorded 2,938 sale and purchase agreements for registration in October. 

The figure translated to a 24.5% decrease compared with September and a 33.9% drop from October 2022.

The total consideration for sale and purchase agreements fell 2.5% MoM and 11.5% YoY from September to $29b.

Of the agreements, 2,123 were for residential units.  The number of sold residential units was down 25.8% from September and 32.6% low

5. HK's foreign currency reserve increased to US$416b 2023-11-08 14:56:20

Hong Kong's foreign currency reserve assets increased to US$416b in August from US$415.7b in September.

According to the Monetary Authority, the reserve assets represent over five times the currency in circulation or about 40% of Hong Kong dollar M3.

“There were no unsettled foreign exchange contracts at end-October and end-September,” added the Monetary Authority.

6. Toronto's home prices fell at the fastest pace 2023-11-09 09:58:46

Toronto's home prices fell at the fastest pace in more than 12 months as the high interest rates that have pressured the market showed little sign of easing.

The benchmark price of a home in Canada's largest city fell to C$1.13 million (HK$6.47 million) in October, down 1.7 percent from September, the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board said last week.

That is the third straight monthly drop and the fastest pace of decline in 15 months.

The seasonally adjusted number of sales also declined five percent from the previous month, to 4,867 transactions - comparable to the deep market freeze of December and January.

7. Sellers suffered heavy losses 2023-11-10 20:32:58

Secondary markets in Hong Kong saw quite a few loss-making transactions last month, with some recording nearly 30 percent losses as high interest rates kept a lid on the price recovery potential despite support measures such as reductions in stamp duties introduced in the recent policy address.

A 629-square-foot, three-bedroom unit at Alto Residences in Tseung Kwan O went for HK$10.88 million, almost a year after it was first put up for sale at HK$16 million.

The owner, who bought in at HK$15.32 million in 2017, suffered a paper loss of HK$4.44 million, or 29 percent, after holding on to the property for six years.